Hydraulics in my Future?

I can be surprisingly conservative with my choice of cycling equipment; take for instance brakes. For a long time I have resisted the disc brakes. While it’s true that I have an mtb with mechanical discs, that configuration had more to do with searching for adequate braking for the road STI levers than a unwavering belief in discs. If cantilever brakes had been an option for the Rock Shox SID fork, I might not have walked down that path. But I did, and I have come to appreciate disc brakes. However, I really think that disc are best matched to hydraulic actuation systems.

XTR st-m975.jpeg

As far as road bikes are concerned, how long must we wait for an integrated shift/brake lever that uses hydraulic fluid rather than a brake cable? The obvious instigator would have to be Shimano, since they’re XTR M975 lever is so close in form to what a hydraulic roadbike STI would need to be. The difficulty in this is that racing drives component development, whether it be mtb or road. That means XTR gets a hydraulic integrated shifter and Dura Ace goes electric. A roadbike hydraulic STI would benefit the mid and high-end touring and roadbike commuter groups, and those groups aren’t lucrative enough to chase with expensive product development.

Still, I’d think it would have to happen someday.


As a member of this niche, it needs to be mentioned that I’m no Rivendellian trapped in the era when Michael Jackson was black, so I can see the argument for discs.  However, I’ll need a stronger argument against mechanical than “disc [brakes] are best matched to hydraulic actuation systems.” It seems to me that mechanical delivers enough of disc brakes’ benefits, without adding complexity for self-supported riders.

i guess i took it as self-evident, having been working on and riding disc brake bikes a lot lately. hydraulics beat the pants off of cable discs in terms of power. and a cable-actuated disc on a road bike doesn’t even come close to a side-pull caliper brake in terms of modulation. hydraulics would be the way to get the most out of that form of brake.  do you cable-discs work? yes. as good as hyrdraulic? no way.

To comment

Or with us.

Advertise here

About this Entry

The Girlfriend’s Bike: new gearing was the previous entry in this blog.

Mobile Social Interbike 2009 is the next one.

Find more recent content on our home page and archives.

Latest Photos

About Bike Hugger