Derailleurs and emails

DA derailleur old.jpg

<

p> The late Sheldon Brown will surely be remembered as the first patron saint of internet cycling lore and has been for me personally an inspiration for technical writing. But none of that mitigates the fact that spelling derailleur as “derailer” is just stupid. The earliest derailleur was created by a Frenchman, the first widely available designs were French, the first commercially successful British products were from a company established through a French partnership, and everyone already spells it “derailleur”.

Sheldon Brown argued that there is a precedent in the English for a railroad mechanism called a “derailer”, but the supposition is that locomotives are more relevant to bicycles than a French invention to move a chain across a cogset.

There is L’Academie francaise (the French Academy), an institution in France, that among other things protects the Frenchness of the language from contaminants like the phrase “quarter pounder with cheese”. A few years ago, the French Academy decreed that the word “email” was un-French and mandated that France would use the word “courriel”. This is short for courrier electronique, the direct transliteration of “electronic mail”. Ever since then, all the French now have a cafe and a croissant in the morning before reading their personal “courriel”.

WAIT! No, they don’t! …because that’s STUPID and everyone knows it to be so. In a gratifying vote for pragmatism, the average Frenchman recognizes the primacy of the Anglo-American word “email” and choses both the status quo and universal clarity.

So remember, kids: D-E-R-A-I-L-L-E-U-R.



8 Comments

POTATOE!

“Courriel” is reasonably common in Quebec, actually, particularly in business and official settings. I hear the word almost every day, though “un email” is still more common. Courriel is a bit more natural to say than email, a bit more elegant. Beginning a noun with the ‘em’ sylable is kind of clunky in French.

I do spell it derailleur, but then I also put u’s into words like colour.

I’m with Sheldon on this, as I’ve told Mark a few times now, The [Ghost of Sheldon Brown](http://bikehugger.com/2010/05/the-derailleur-ler.html) commands you.

Using “derailleur,” reeks of US soccer teams using “FC.” Still it’s common use so I still use “derailleur.” Common use rules all.

@Byron

D-E-A-D

@Bruce

English is a “borrowing” language, and I think English-speakers should return the borrowed words without modification.  And I find nothing humourous in poor spelling.  But French speakers really should return the favour and just stick to “email”.

Careful, I’ve got the Publisher title backing up my decisions on what spelling conventions to use.

If I owned a 650b, I would then say things in French just to be more French like. I’d also run my veloputer in kilos and spell tires, “tyres.”

I’ll rebut by letting this speak for itself (emphasis mine):

The other day at the bike shop, the Vittoria rep came by. Vittoria shoes, not tyres... I see less of the keirin and Euro influences lately and more of the BMX and skateboard flavour...

To comment

Or with us.





Advertise here

About this Entry

Four Schwinns was the previous entry in this blog.

Efficient Velo Tools is the next one.

Find more recent content on our home page and archives.

About Bike Hugger